If you’re planning a trip to New York City, few experiences capture the energy and excitement of the Big Apple quite like Broadway in Times Square. From timeless classics that have dazzled audiences for decades to the latest buzzworthy productions making their debut, there’s something for everyone under the glittering lights of the Theater District.
Whether you’re a first-time visitor looking for the ultimate NYC experience or a seasoned theatergoer chasing the next big hit, these are the best Broadway shows in NYC that promise an unforgettable night out.
Located just a 10-minute walk from The Carnegie Hotel, the Times Square area is the vibrant heart of New York’s entertainment scene. This iconic neighborhood is packed with more than 40 theaters in Times Square, each offering world-class productions that range from beloved family musicals to provocative plays and groundbreaking revivals.
Whether you arrive for a matinee or catch an evening show after exploring other things to do in Times Square, NY, the area’s neon-lit energy and constant buzz make it one of the most electric destinations in the world.
Some Broadway productions have become as much a part of New York’s identity as the Empire State Building or Central Park. These shows continue to thrill audiences year after year, offering unforgettable performances and music that stays with you long after the curtain falls.
This Disney masterpiece has been enchanting audiences for over 25 years, and it’s easy to see why. The spectacular costumes, breathtaking puppetry, and powerful score by Elton John and Tim Rice bring the Pride Lands to life in a way that’s nothing short of magical. Located just a 10-minute walk from The Carnegie Hotel, The Lion King is a must-see for visitors of all ages.
Step behind the curtain of Oz and discover the untold story of the Wicked Witch and Glinda the Good. With its soaring vocals and emotional depth, Wicked has become one of Broadway’s most beloved and enduring shows. Only a 10-minute walk from the hotel, it’s perfect for fans of dazzling set design, friendship, and powerful storytelling.
If you love razzle-dazzle, sultry jazz numbers, and timeless choreography, Chicago delivers in spades. The longest-running American musical in Broadway history continues to impress with its sizzling score and sharp wit. It’s about a 10-minute stroll from The Carnegie Hotel, making it an easy choice for a glamorous night out.
Lin-Manuel Miranda’s revolutionary musical has redefined modern Broadway. With its fusion of hip-hop, R&B, and historical storytelling, Hamilton offers a dynamic and emotional exploration of America’s founding. This hot-ticket production remains one of the best Broadway shows in NYC, and it’s just a quick 15-minute walk from The Carnegie Hotel.
Each season, Broadway welcomes a new wave of shows that push boundaries and capture the cultural moment. From film adaptations to original works, these productions are drawing crowds and critical acclaim.
This vibrant new musical celebrates Bobby Darin’s life and enduring hits, blending biographical storytelling with period‑style swing, pop, and jazz. Whether you’re discovering Darin for the first time or revisiting his classics, Just in Time offers a spirited and fresh Broadway experience, just a short 10-minute walk from The Carnegie Hotel.
Get ready to dance in your seat! This feel-good musical, set to the timeless hits of ABBA, brings sunshine, laughter, and romance to Broadway. With its infectious energy and heartwarming story of love and family, Mamma Mia! is a must-see for anyone looking for pure joy in musical form. The Winter Garden Theatre is less than 10 minutes from The Carnegie Hotel.
Adapted from S.E. Hinton’s classic novel, The Outsiders offers a deeply emotional coming-of-age story set to a stunning score by the folk-rock duo Jamestown Revival. This new musical has captured audiences with its heartfelt performances and fresh approach to an American classic—just a nice 15-minute walk from The Carnegie Hotel.
Before or after your Broadway adventure, Times Square offers countless dining and entertainment options. Grab a pre-show dinner at a local favorite like Carmine’s or Becco, or toast to the evening afterward at one of the neighborhood’s stylish rooftop bars.
Between the twinkling billboards, street performers, and the world-famous TKTS booth (where you can snag discounted same-day tickets), there’s no shortage of things to do in Times Square, NY, before heading into the theater.
No trip to New York City is complete without experiencing the magic of Broadway in Times Square. From long-standing legends like The Lion King and Wicked to fresh, show-stopping hits like Mamma Mia! and The Outsiders, the city’s Theater District promises unforgettable memories night after night.
After the curtain falls, return to comfort and elegance at The Carnegie Hotel, conveniently located within walking distance of the top theaters in Times Square. With its luxurious accommodations and unbeatable location, the Carnegie is the perfect place to unwind after an evening spent enjoying the very best of Broadway.
Book your stay today for a star-studded night on Broadway in Times Square!